For hours the ocean interrogates the wooden vessel but receives no answer.
The air on the deck is empty, as if the soul of the boat has seeped through the cracked boards and been lost at sea.
It is neither hot nor cold, neither fair nor stormy. The sky is smeared with fat, and the sea is a cup of rinsed paintbrushes.
At last, a murmur. It spills into the void, descending from the high and creaky crow’s nest.
“I’m Popeye… the Sailor-Man. I live… I live…”
A shriller voice interjects from somewhere below. “You live in a garbage can!”
Popeye seems not to hear. His good eye fixes the middle-distance. He scratches under his cap.
“Do I?” Popeye asks the ocean. “No, that can’t be right.”
On the deck below, a rat wanders out of an overturned barrel.
“Well blow me down,” Popeye says suddenly, staring out. “Wimpy old pal! Find a hamburger? Hope so! Hamburger shamburger, you can have ‘em.”
The scrawny rat waddles toward a pile of fly-specked bones, begins nibbling.
“Watch out for ol’ Bluto, Wimpy,” Popeye continues, gnawing a smokeless corncob pipe. “Real mean one, I’d like to eat HIS lunch, see?”
A tall, emaciated woman appears on deck. Her skin is old leather, her hair wild. “Popeye!”
“Yes, that’s it. I’m Popeye the Sailor-Man. I live… no, not live. But I’m strong see? Strong where? Strong to… the finich! Cuz…”
“Popeye!” the woman calls again, louder this time.
“…cuz why?” Popeye continues. “Because I fight? No, all wrong. What do I do? I… eats? Yes! I strong to the finich, cuz I eats my—”
“POPEYE, LOOK!” the woman howls.
Popeye blinks his eye and leans over. “Well shiver me timbers, Olive Oyl.”
“KILL IT, POPEYE!” Olive Oyl shrieks, pointing to the rat, which goes on worrying a rib bone.
Popeye returns to his thoughts. “That’s not it at all, Olive ol’ gal. That’s not what I eat, cuz I’s eats my—”
“Oh Popeye, you’re dreaming!” Olive moans. “DREAMING while we STARVE!”
Popeye points at the sea with his pipe. “Starve, yeah, I starve if I don’t eats my—”
Olive creeps toward the rodent on her tippy-toes. She reaches for something on the deck.
“My—” Popeye repeats, searching for the word.
With two hands, Olive lifts the something.
“My—” Popeye says again.
Olive raises the something high above her head.
“Friends!” Popeye concludes.
With all her strength, Olive Oyl brings the skull crashing down onto the rat.
* * *
Night falls, but as on all the nights since The Fall, the stars go unseen.
Olive Oyl picks her teeth with a rat’s clawed foot. Popeye’s good eye reflects the fire.
“You shoulda eaten, Pop-eye,” Olive says. “You needa keep up your strength!”
“No good, see?” Popeye says. “No good at all. Wimpy had food but couldn’t make it. Then WE had Wimpy.”
“Don’t talk like that, Pop-eye!” Olive whines. “We did what we had to. Fooey!”
“Amazed his skull worked,” Popeye says. “Thought I caved it in. Always was a hard head though. I mean that i-ronical, Olive. I-ronical.”
From the ocean, somewhere nearby, a boat horn emanates. Olive continues screaming even after it has stopped.
Popeye, veteran seaman, is unphased.
“Visitors eh,” Popeye says. “Bout time, big sea but bout time.” He toots his pipe twice.
Two lights stare back like eyeballs. The ship emerges from the fog, a hulking patchwork of scrap metal.
A voice booms across the water. “AHOY!”
“Ahoy,” Popeye mutters. “Ahoy. We’re rescued, hooray.”
“Hello!” Olive Oyl cries. “Hello! We’re here! Oh, please help us! Over here!”
Soon the ships are side-by-side. Popeye catches a rope that whistles out of the other boat’s blinding on-board lights.
“Oh thank goodness,” Olive is saying. Popeye strains to see the other sailor, whose silhouette bobs with the waves.
Popeye ties the rope. “We were so worried,” Olive is saying. “We thought—” Olive’s voice stops. She screams.
Popeye looks up. He sees the fist coming. At long last, he sees stars again. Everything goes dark.
* * *
Popeye opens his eye wide. There is steam everywhere. His hands are tied. He is standing in water. Olive Oil moans somewhere close by.
He looks down. A metal vessel— a pot. He is standing in water in a big metal pot. The water is hot, steaming.
He tries to open his mouth to breathe, but can’t. His lips sting. He looks down again, at his rippling reflection. He screams in his throat.
His lips are stitched together.
He looks around frantically, his legs tied too. He hops toward the side of the pot. The rim burns his chest. Something hits his forehead.
Popeye thinks he is going to die.
“Alright, hoist him!” The voice is like a clap of thunder. Popeye feels a yanking at his back. He rises slowly out of the water.
“Get ‘im out of the steam,” the deep voice says, with a big sigh. Popeye levitates into the sudden coldness of the room. His eye waters.
“There you are!” the voice chortles. Popeye recognizes the massive toon at once.
“Brr-brw” Popeye manages through his stitched lips. His chin tickles and he wonders if it is blood.
“HA HA HA!” The big toon leans back, slapping his belly. “Brr-brw? That’s not my name at all, Popeye!”
The big toon nods to someone unseen, and Popeye begins levitating back. Backwards toward the pot.
“You look like a worm on a fishing line!” the big toon crows. “Wriggling on that rope, you look like a stuck worm!”
Before the steam curtain conceals it, Popeye sees the big toon open a door. In the room beyond, Olive Oyl lays tied to a bed, struggling.
Popeye screams and struggles against the ropes. He starts swinging back and forth, a desperate pendulum. “Take his knees!” Bluto shouts.
The clubs breaking his knee caps knocks Popeye out. He reawakens as his limp feet touch the now-boiling water.
“How’s that song go, Popeye? ‘I’m one tough Gazookus who hates all Palookas?’ Not so tough now, are ya boy?”
Popeye squeezes his eye. He thinks he may be screaming. Bluto continues to sing. “Oh I biffs ‘em and buffs ‘em! And always out roughs ‘em!”
Up to his thighs now, Popeye sees another, smaller pot overturned into his. The splash sends molten droplets against his face.
Below him, vegetables bob in the water like loose buoys in a squall.
Passingly, between those vegetables, he once more sees his reflection. And his sewn lips.
Popeye strains to break the stitches. He must tell Olive Oyl goodbye. He must curse Bluto one last time.
Massive jaw throbbing, he pulls. He pulls until the blood gushes into the boiling tempest below, until his upper lip begins to tear.
Just as the water reaches his chin, with one last heave, Popeye pulls his upper lip free, stitches and all, and opens his mouth to scream.
…too late. The water rushes in, choking his words. He feels it coarse down his throat, filling his stomach. Popeye begins to drown.
Bluto sings above Olive Oyl’s moaning. “If anyone dares to risk my fisk, it’s boff an’ it’s wham, un’erstan?”
Popeye floats motionless.
A long fork is pointed at the pot, prods Popeye’s forehead. Whispers rise with the steam.
And then Popeye wakes up.
His hand, flesh hanging, darts from the steam, finds a throat. As the toon backpeddles, Popeye is pulled from the cauldron.
Pushing himself up, Popeye kneels on his broken legs. He sucks the last of the green seaweed-like goo past his lip-less yellow teeth.
Seeing it on the floor, Popeye flings the long fork into the toon’s right eye. It sails clear through the skull, brain matter skewered.
Popeye crawls forward, grabs a tablecloth. An oil lamp explodes on the floor as silverware clatters all around. He finds a knife.
Bluto sings, panting, voice husky. “So keep good be-hav-or, that’s your one life saver, with Popeye the Sailor Man.”
Trailing blood, skin puckered like paint on an old boat, Popeye raises himself to his knees once more, and throws himself against the door.
Popeye lands, looks up, cocks back with his huge forearm, and lets fly.
The spinning knife cleanly severs Bluto’s turgid penis, mere inches from Olive Oyl’s screaming face. Blood escapes in a crimson pillar.
With great howls, Bluto falls off the bed in a paroxysm of pain. Popeye is already crawling. He heaves himself onto the larger toon.
Popeye’s fingers dig through layers of fat to the windpipe. Bluto’s eyes bulge. Popeye seethes blood.
“I strong to the finich,” Popeye croaks. “Cause I eats me spinach.” He squeezes as if breaking rock, waiting for Bluto’s life to drain.
At last, with a parting seizure, Bluto goes still. Popeye rolls away, and Olive Oyl’s face appears above, covered in blood, haloed by smoke.
* * *
At the prow of the boat, Olive Oyl cradles Popeye. They watch the smoke billow up from cracks all around.
“Oh it’s better this way, Pop-eye,” Olive is saying. Popeye takes the pipe from his teeth to cough blood. “Yea shiver me timbers, Olive.”
As the boat sinks, the old sailor looks to the sky. Not a star. He looks to the sea, to the fiery reflection on the waves and the circling fins.
Popeye toots his pipe twice.